Buddy (2026) Review: A Candy-Coloured Nightmare Behind the Screen
Casper Kelly’s killer unicorn delivers gory, unpredictable horror that stumbles only slightly late on.
UK Platform/Release: UK cinemas, 27 November 2026 | BBFC Rating: BBFC 15 | Runtime/Episodes: 95 minutes
Scorecard & Industry Consensus
OUR RATING: ★ ★ ★ ★ ☆ (7.5 / 10)
Verdict: Unexpected, gory and gripping
| Category | Score | Key Takeaway |
|---|---|---|
| Story & Narrative Realism | 4.0/5.0 | An intriguing premise whose layered mysteries keep you guessing without being given away. |
| Performances & Chemistry | 3.5/5.0 | The unicorn’s sudden shifts from friend to threat are chilling, and they carry the film. |
| Production & Set Pieces | 4.0/5.0 | The recreated nineties children’s-television set is playful on the surface and sinister underneath. |
| Pacing & Tension | 3.5/5.0 | Curiosity holds you throughout, though the second half feels noticeably uneven. |
| Sound Design & Score | 3.5/5.0 | Buddy’s arrivals are drawn out with menace, so every entrance produces genuine dread. |
Industry Consensus (Reference Only):
- Rotten Tomatoes: 88% (Critics)
- IMDb: 6.6 / 10
- Metacritic: 67 / 100
Quick Audience Guide
| Watch It If | Skip It If |
|---|---|
| You enjoy horror, unusual premises, supernatural storytelling and plenty of gore, or admired Obsession and Backrooms for how they surprised you. | You are planning a family viewing: the bloodshed and adult content, including a brief LGBTQ+ moment involving a toy character, are not for younger audiences. |
The Standout Moment: The first full reveal of Buddy’s true nature, when the cheerful unicorn drops the act in front of the children, turns a sugary nineties set into something genuinely terrifying.
High-Impact Pros & Cons
Pros
- Relentless Curiosity: The mystery of how the children arrived, and what is real, sustains curiosity until the final frame.
- Terrifying Menace: Every appearance by Buddy is genuinely frightening, and the film wrings dread from what he might say or do next.
- Committed Gore: Generous, bloody set pieces give horror fans the carnage they came for, and the film relishes it.
- Fresh Premise: A killer unicorn haunting a nineties children’s television show feels unlike anything else in recent supernatural horror.
Cons
- Uneven Second Half: The second half feels uneven, and the pacing wavers once the central mysteries begin to unfold.
- Execution Gaps: Small shortcomings suggest the execution could have been sharper, keeping a strong concept from reaching its full potential.
Deep Editorial Critique
Direction & Tactical Realism
Casper Kelly’s film is built on a deceptively simple conceit. It’s Buddy! is a nineties-style children’s programme hosted by a bright orange unicorn who adores the children on his set, talks to them warmly and dispenses gentle lessons. The sets are bright, the children are playing, and everything looks as familiar as the television of that era. Then the host shows the children his true face, and his capacity for cruelty and bloodshed becomes impossible to ignore.
What lifts Buddy above a one-joke premise is the questions it raises. How did these children arrive here, and why can none of them remember? Is the programme a reflection of reality, and will the real world intrude on it? The film answers these, and the real world and Buddy’s world both come into play, but it releases its secrets carefully. This review stays deliberately spoiler-free, because discovery is half the pleasure. From the opening scenes to the end, the audience is driven by one question: what exactly is the film trying to show us?
That curiosity is the film’s greatest strength, but it is also where the film falters. The story is strong, yet the second half feels uneven, and the execution at times falls short of the ambition. These are modest blemishes rather than fatal ones, but they separate a very good horror film from an exceptional one.
Production Scale & Visual Impact
The production design commits fully to the aesthetic of nineties children’s television: a candy-coloured set, a cheerful host and children playing as though nothing could go wrong. That brightness is the point, because it makes each violent rupture land harder. The gore is plentiful, with the bloodshed delivered unflinchingly. Horror enthusiasts will find it satisfying, though squeamish viewers should heed the BBFC 15 certificate.
Sound plays its part in the dread. Buddy’s arrivals are staged to feel genuinely terrifying, and the anticipation of what he might say or do to the children often unsettles more than the violence itself.
Performances & Tension
Buddy is the film’s centre of gravity. Keegan-Michael Key voices the unicorn, and the character’s rapid shifts from affectionate friend to terrifying threat are what make the film’s tension work. Cristin Milioti leads the human cast as Grace, and the ensemble of children grounds the film’s mysteries with a credible sense of confusion. Tension is sustained largely by curiosity, since the audience wants answers as urgently as the characters do. It slackens somewhat in the second half, but never enough to loosen the film’s grip.
On balance, Buddy is an unexpected and often remarkable experience that rewards horror audiences willing to embrace something strange. Fans of Obsession and Backrooms should seek it out.

Rachel Rosie is a Writer & Editor at BriefLedger, based in London, UK. She holds a BA (Hons) in Journalism and Publishing from the University of the Arts London (UAL). Rachel writes about entertainment, culture, television, movies and trending stories, with a focus on clear, engaging and well-researched content.
